Ultraviolet exposure and the development of banal and atypical naevi - A cross-sectional study on Curacao and in The Netherlands

The atypical naevus is both a risk factor for and a precursor lesion of melanoma. Sunlight is known to be an important aetiological factor for melanoma. Whether solar exposure is also involved in the initiation of (atypical) naevi is an issue of current interest. We performed a cross- sectional study among 270 inhabitants in the cloudy Netherlands and 282 white Dutch immigrants of the tropical island Curacao to investigate whether solar exposure plays a role in the development of atypical naevi. All participants were interviewed and underwent total skin examination; banal melanocytic naevi and atypical naevi were counted. There was no significant difference in the mean number of melanocytic naevi ≤ 2 mm or ≤ 5 mm between Curacao and the Netherlands. Furthermore, there was no significant difference in the mean crude and age standardized prevalence of atypical naevi between the Netherlands and Curacao. In both groups individuals with atypical naevi had significantly more total naevi. Concerning the role of sun exposure in the development of naevi in the Netherlands, we found that the total naevus count had a significant association with cumulative sun exposure before the age of 12 as well as with two or more painful sunburns before the age of 12. In Curacao these relationships were not observed. In contrast, however, on Curacao the presence of atypical naevi showed an association (odds ratio = 2.6, 95% confidence interval 1.1-6.0) with the highest level of cumulative sun exposure and with painful sunburns before the age of 12 (odds ratio = 2.6, 95% confidence interval 1.2-5.5). In the Dutch group these associations were not significant. We hypothesize that in the development of banal naevi there is an association between the total number of naevi and sun exposure only at low exposure levels; however, after overstepping a critical threshold a further association between melanocytic naevi and sun exposure is lacking. Sunlight exposure before the age of 12 plays a complex role: only very high exposure levels seem to contribute to the development of atypical naevi.