Muscle-driven predictive physics simulations of quadrupedal locomotion in the horse

Pasha A van Bijlert*, Thomas Geijtenbeek, Ineke H Smit, Anne S Schulp, Karl T Bates

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Musculoskeletal simulations can provide insights into the underlying mechanisms that govern animal locomotion. In this study, we describe the development of a new musculoskeletal model of the horse, and to our knowledge present the first fully muscle-driven, predictive simulations of equine locomotion. Our goal was to simulate a model that captures only the gross musculoskeletalstructure of a horse, withoutspecialized morphological features. We mostly presentsimulations acquired using feedforward control,withoutstate feedback ("top-down control"). Without using kinematics or motion capture data as an input, we have simulated a variety of gaitsthat are commonly used by horses(walk, pace, trot, t lt, and collected gallop). We also found a selection of gaits that are not normally seen in horses (half bound, extended gallop, ambling). Due to the clinical relevance of the trot, we performed a tracking simulation that included empirical joint angle deviations in the cost function. To further demonstrate the flexibility of our model, we also present a simulation acquired using spinal feedback control, where muscle control signals are wholly determined by gait kinematics. Despite simplifications to the musculature, simulated footfalls and ground reaction forces followed empirical patterns. In the tracking simulation, kinematics improved with respect to the fully predictive simulations, and muscle activations showed a reasonable correspondence to electromyographic signals, although we did not predict any anticipatory firing of muscles. When sequentially increasing the targetspeed, oursimulationsspontaneously predicted walk-to-run transitions at the empirically determined speed. However, predicted stride lengths were too short over nearly the entire speed range unless explicitly prescribed in the controller, and we also did not recover spontaneous transitions to asymmetric gaits such as galloping. Taken together, our model performed adequately when simulating individual gaits, but our simulation workflow was not able to capture all aspects of gait selection. We point out certain aspects of our workflow that may have caused this, including anatomical simplifications and the use of massless Hill-type actuators. Our model is an extensible, generalized horse model, with considerable scope for adding anatomical complexity. This project is intended as a starting point for continual development of the model and code that we make available in extensible open-source formats.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)694-714
Number of pages21
JournalIntegrative and Comparative Biology
Volume64
Issue number3
Early online date13 Jul 2024
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sept 2024

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology.

Funding

We thank Claudia Wolschrijn and the Department of Clinical Sciences, section Anatomy and Physiology at the Veterinary Sciences Faculty of Utrecht University for providing permission to 3D scan their mounted horse skeleton and several of their plastinates. We thank Ton van den Bogert for mailing us a physical copy of his PhD thesis, and extensive discussions on equine locomotion. We thank William Sellers for discussions on animal locomotion and for sharing Sandra Starke's MSc thesis with us. We received in-depth feedback during the 2024 SICB meeting-we are very grateful to Delyle Polet, Jim Usherwood, Craig McGowan, Janneke Schwaner, Taylor Dick, and Christofer Clemente for these discussions. Meret Spithoven is thanked for pointing out several errors after a critical reading of the manuscript. We also extend our gratitude to four anonymous reviewers who helped improve this manuscript.DAS:We have constructed a project page on SimTK (a biomechanics repository): https://simtk.org/projects/shadowfax. SHADOWFAX stands for Simulated Horse Anatomy Demonstrating Optimal Walking & Fast ACCeleration. Our models, simulator outputs, and example scripts are reposited on this project page.

FundersFunder number
Company of Biologists
Department of Clinical Sciences, section Anatomy and Physiology at the Veterinary Sciences Faculty of Utrecht University

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Muscle-driven predictive physics simulations of quadrupedal locomotion in the horse'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this