Abstract
Previous studies show that young, typically developing (TD) children (<age 5) and children with specific language impairment (SLI; >age 5) make errors in the choice between a definite and an indefinite article. Suggested explanations for overgeneration of the definite article include failure to distinguish speaker from hearer assumptions, and for overgeneration of the indefinite article failure to draw scalar implicatures, and weak working memory. However, no direct empirical evidence for these accounts is available. In this study, 27 Dutch-speaking children with high-functioning autism, 27 children with SLI, and 27 TD children aged 5-14 were administered a pragmatic article choice test, a nonverbal theory of mind test, and three types of memory tests (phonological memory, verbal, and nonverbal working memory). The results show that the children with high-functioning autism and SLI (a) make similar errors, that is, they overgenerate the indefinite article; (b) are TD-like at theory of mind, but (c) perform significantly more poorly than the TD children on phonological memory and verbal working memory. We propose that weak memory skills prevent the integration of the definiteness scale with the preceding discourse, resulting in the failure to consistently draw the relevant scalar implicature. This in turn yields the occasional erroneous choice of the indefinite article a in definite contexts.
Original language | English |
---|---|
Pages (from-to) | 89-115 |
Number of pages | 27 |
Journal | Applied Psycholinguistics |
Volume | 39 |
Issue number | 1 |
DOIs | |
Publication status | Published - 1 Jan 2018 |
Bibliographical note
Funding Information:This project was made financially possible by the Priority Area Amsterdam Brain & Cognition, University of Amsterdam. Data on SLI was collected in collaboration with Iris Duinmeijer and our research assistants: Jorik Geutjes, Doatske de Haan, Leanne Matimba, Irene Rademaker, Kim Schoof, and Sybren Spit. We are grateful to all the schools, children, teachers, and parents who participated in this study.
Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2017 Cambridge University Press.
Funding
This project was made financially possible by the Priority Area Amsterdam Brain & Cognition, University of Amsterdam. Data on SLI was collected in collaboration with Iris Duinmeijer and our research assistants: Jorik Geutjes, Doatske de Haan, Leanne Matimba, Irene Rademaker, Kim Schoof, and Sybren Spit. We are grateful to all the schools, children, teachers, and parents who participated in this study.
Keywords
- article choice
- high-functioning autism
- phonological and working memory
- specific language impairment
- theory of mind